Showing posts with label Pakistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pakistan. Show all posts

Friday, September 12, 2008

Krauthammer Unwittingly Hands My Ass to Me

In yesterday's post, I invoked the "Bush Doctrine." Interestingly enough, about the same time, ABC's Palin interview also invoked a "Bush Doctrine," but it was a very different thing he was talking about.

To me, the Doctrine was our policy of treating regimes that harbor terrorists as hostile--the justification for the war in Afghanistan. To ABC's Gibson, the Doctrine was preemptive war--which he incorrectly attributes to being the justification for the war in Iraq and perhaps other future wars as well. (I say incorrectly because Iraq was sold as a preventative war, not a preemptive war. This "Bush Doctrine" was a new and controversial concept borne out of the risks of rogue states or terrorists acquiring WMD. Anticipatory self-defense/preemption applies to strikes against military forces which are poised to or are mobilizing to strike. It is not new and is widely accepted.)

But as Krauthammer points out, we're both wrong:

There is no single meaning of the Bush Doctrine. In fact, there have been four distinct meanings, each one succeeding another over the eight years of this administration -- and the one Charlie Gibson cited is not the one in common usage today. It is utterly different.


The first was American unilateralism with respect to the ABM treaty and Kyoto; Krauthammer himself coined the term "Bush Doctrine" to refer to the administration's unilateral approach.

The second was the one I used.

The third was the one Gibson used.

And the fourth--and current--use of the Bush Doctrine is nothing other than conventional tried-and-true liberalism:

...the fourth and current definition of the Bush doctrine, the most sweeping formulation of the Bush approach to foreign policy and the one that most clearly and distinctively defines the Bush years: the idea that the fundamental mission of American foreign policy is to spread democracy throughout the world. It was most dramatically enunciated in Bush's second inaugural address: "The survival of liberty in our land increasingly depends on the success of liberty in other lands. The best hope for peace in our world is the expansion of freedom in all the world."


Applying that doctrine to the Pakistan issue, it would seem that the moral imperative of going after AQ/the Taliban wherever they are is much diminished in the face of the overriding priority of spreading freedom into "the Gap."

So, I was wrong. You don't suppose Gibson will admit that he was wrong too, do you?

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Pakistan and the Bush Doctrine

"The search is underway for those who are behind these evil acts. I've directed the full resources of our intelligence and law enforcement communities to find those responsible and to bring them to justice.

We will make no distinction between the terrorists who committed these acts and those who harbor them."

President George W. Bush, 9/11/01

This morning, NYT reportedthat although we will notify Pakistan about any future border crossing by our troops, we will not ask for permission. Pakistan is, quite predictably, pissed off about that. I don't think they have much room to talk though. It's not exactly a secret that the Taliban is running a government in exile from the border regions. And Pakistan isn't exerting much control in those areas, leaving them semi autonomous. If they want to claim sovereignty, shouldn't they be exercising it? If all they are going to do is refuse us access, what's the difference between what they are doing now and that the Taliban/Afghanistan did with respect to Al Queda in 2001?

Unfortunately, I don't think the question is this simple, because there is more going on here than the routing of the Taliban insurgency. Pakistan itself is on a major precipice right now. And in transitioning from being run by a dictator to a true democracy, they have an opportunity to do for themselves through the political process what we did for Iraq with our military. The next year could decide whether Pakistan becomes a modern, moderate Muslim democracy, or goes the way of Iran--except that they already have nuclear weapons. The future of Pakistan is far more important than capturing Bin Laden or finishing off the Taliban. For this reason, I don't think incensing the Pakistani populace against us is a good move right now.

It's lose-lose either way. If we sit back and rely on negotiations--which we have been doing--not much is going to change. The Taliban insurgency will continue, and it isn't at all clear that an Afghan "surge" would be successful, because "The Surge" was simply providing Iraq with the troops necessary to carry out the Petraeus strategy. I doubt that this strategy--including such operations as clearing and holding insurgent safe havens--can be successful in an battlefield where the biggest safe haven of all is politically off-limits. So, maintaining cooperation with Pakistan, short of a diplomatic miracle, means a longer war in Afghanistan, complete with the military and civilian casualties, expenditures, and wear-and-tear on our equipment that comes with that.

But for the time being, I think a longer war in Afghanistan is worth a good chance at a bloodless "victory" in Pakistan, and is favorable to dealing with than two Iran's.